Holiday Humor: Rudolph the Approval Seeking Pariah

Warning: Reading this post may tarnish some of your fond childhood memories…

“Rudolph, the Red-Nosed Reindeer,” is one of the most popular Christmas songs of all time. If you are unfamiliar, or need a refresher, here are the lyrics:

rudolph_the_rednosed_reindeerRudolph, the red-nosed reindeer
had a very shiny nose.
And if you ever saw him,
you would even say it glows.

All of the other reindeer
used to laugh and call him names.
They never let poor Rudolph
join in any reindeer games.

Then one foggy Christmas Eve
Santa came to say:
“Rudolph with your nose so bright,
won’t you guide my sleigh tonight?”

Then all the reindeer loved him
as they shouted out with glee,
Rudolph the red-nosed reindeer,
you’ll go down in history!

Wasn’t that nice? Doesn’t that make you feel good? Doesn’t that fill you with hope and Christmas cheer?

Well it shouldn’t.

While on the surface, Rudolph is a happy song about an underdog overcoming to become the most famous reindeer ever, there is a hidden, much darker meaning in the song.

The Real Message of Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer:

If You Are Different, Society Will Shun You, *Unless* Said Difference Proves Useful, At Which Point Society Will Exploit You

Think about it: until a meteorological phenomenon was about to impede Santa’s annual gift giving bonanza, Rudolph was shunned and mocked. However, as soon as Santa needed high-beams that only Rudolph could provide, Rudolph became a hero.

Doesn’t this sound a bit like the nerdy kid in high school who couldn’t get a date but then goes on to start a multi-million dollar software company and now all of a sudden all the women who previously shunned him are throwing themselves at him?

Think Bill Gates was a ladies man in high school? Think he’d have any trouble getting a date now? <br /> (The high school IT nerd: The "Rudolph" of our generation)

Think Bill Gates was a ladies man in high school? Think he’d have any trouble getting a date now?
(The high school IT nerd: The "Rudolph" of our generation)


There’s no heart-warming lesson here. The reindeer don’t look past Rudolph’s slight proboscis problem to see his inner beauty and accept him for who he is. If Santa had never come along, they would have continued to shun and mock Rudolph to the point where he became the “Boo Radley” of reindeers.

Actually, being herd creatures, their shunning of Rudolph probably just would have resulted in him being ravaged by a pack of wolverines.

Fortunately for Rudolph (and the entire Santa gift-receiving world), Rudolph’s nose glowed, so he became accepted. Can you imagine what would have happened if Rudolph’s nose had been green, wrinkled, and non-glowy? Two words for you: “Wolverine Buffet.”

If not for Santa’s intervention, Rudolph would have been devoured by wolverines

If not for Santa’s intervention, Rudolph would have been devoured by wolverines


This song, sung with glee around the holidays by children and adults, seems so happy and inspiring, and yet it is the exact opposite.

I’m not saying you shouldn’t sing it. And I’m not saying you should ban your children from singing it. But maybe they next time they do, you sit them down and remind them, “you know, those other reindeer were wrong to have mocked Rudolph, and even if Santa had never come along and given Rudolph his stamp of approval, the other reindeer should have accepted and loved Rudolph anyway. Or at least gotten to know him. Or just left him alone to live his life in peace.” I’m just sayin’…

Here are three simple lessons you can take away from Holiday Humor: Rudolph the Approval Seeking Pariah:

  1. Look past physical beauty – That ridiculously handsome dude may eat babies in his spare time, while that girl with the glowing red nose may be the coolest person ever. Take a sec to find out.
  2. Approval Schmapproval! – Perhaps the real issue with “Rudolph” is how important it makes it to be accepted and approved of. It’s nice to be liked, but you can’t live your life seeking approval from everyone. Work on being happy, proud, and comfortable with yourself. Hard lessons for kids to accept, but as adults, this is the way to go. Besides, if no one disapproves of what you’re doing, you’re probably not doing enough.
  3. Sometimes the message isn’t the message – Children’s tales are filled with stories that explicitly have one moral but, upon further inspection, carry deeper subtle messages that aren’t so positive. The next time you are reading a story, or giving a speech, or designing an ad, or simply using an example to prove a point, take a second to think if there are other ways your communication could be interpreted. You might be surprised by how you are undermining your own point

So go forth and sing your Rudolph songs, but when it’s all said and done, make sure you also spread the holiday sentiments of courtesy, acceptance, and love for all to counter the sad depressing message of Rudolph, the Approval Seeking Pariah…

Posted in Just Funny, Motivation & Success | Tagged | 1 Comment

The World’s Worst Motivational Exercises

What do waterboarding, burning, beating, and kidnapping all have in common?

If you said, “they are all controversial tools in the war on terror,” you would be wrong.

If you said, “they were all used as teambuilding and motivational corporate activities,” you would be correct!

Cracked.com posted this very funny – and yet disturbing – article about 6 Motivational Exercises That Went Horribly Wrong.

Yes, all four of the above torture acts, along with two more, are on the list.

Teambuilding activity or bizarre Eli Roth torture porn horror movie? You be the judge...

Teambuilding activity or bizarre Eli Roth torture porn horror movie? You be the judge...


After you read the article, you will probably think three things:

  1. “It is sad that people exist in the world who think some of these things were good motivational ideas”
  2. “It is amazing what people will do when commanded to by an authority figure – or when they feel their job is on the line”
  3. “Boy, I am glad I don’t work for any of those companies!”

Kind of makes hiring a Motivational Smart Ass as your conference speaker or using improv comedy at your next teambuilding or training retreat seem like a no-brainer, doesn’t it?

Posted in Just Funny | 1 Comment

Are You “Prepared” to Improvise?

\"Flying away on a wing and a prayer\" is not a good strategy for life...

"Flying away on a wing and a prayer" is not a good strategy for life...

There’s a difference between “winging it,” and “being able to improvise.” Great improvisers understand that the better you prepare, the better you improvise. I was reminded of this as I watched a humorously minor tragedy befall a young Philadelphia student recently.

I was walking to a meeting through the streets of Philadelphia, when a suddenly heard a rather aggressive thumping of footsteps running up behind me. Using my cat like martial arts reflexes I slowly and slightly turned my head to see what was going on? Was I being attacked? Was a friend running up to say hello? Was Ashton Kutcher about to “Punk’d” me?

It turned out to be nothing that exciting. A young guy, clearly a student, was running to catch the bus that had just passed by. I assume he was a student because he had a sweatshirt with a school’s name on it and he was carrying a backpack full of books. I could tell he had a school sweatshirt because I can read. I could tell his backpack was full of books because of what happened next.

He had run past me and was about half the distance to the bus, when all of a sudden the books and notebooks come tumbling out of his bag! Oh no! It seems his bag was not properly zipped up…

The guy freezes for a second as his eyes go wide. He looks at the bus, then at his books, then back at the bus. All seems hopeless.

But wait! There is a glimmer of hope. The bus has stopped at a red light! The guy quickly scrambles to gather up all his belongings. This takes longer than you might think, as he had a very full backpack. Fortunately (for him, not for me when I’m driving) this is also a very long red light.

He manages to gather up the last of his books just as the light changes green. He breaks into a sprint as the bus slooooowly begins to accelerate. He reaches the corner just as the bus pulls beyond it, screaming out a desperate, “HOLD THE BUS!”

Hey, even Spiderman misses the bus on occasion

Hey, even Spiderman misses the bus on occasion

But it is to no avail. The bus continues on without our young hero, who is now faced with the overwhelmingly depressing task of waiting ten minutes for the next one.

What was his response to missing the bus? He slams the pile of books and papers on to the ground in frustration. Seems a bit ironic, since his books and papers falling to the ground was the source of his whole problem. The Smart Ass in me half hoped another bus would come along at that moment that he would have to miss because he was picking up the papers he himself had thrown down…

I felt bad for the kid. It’s a pain to miss a bus that you can actually see right in front of you, especially when it’s due to a unexpected event.

But I also couldn’t help but thinking, “you know, if he had just made sure his bag was properly zipped up before he left he wouldn’t have this problem.”

There’s a lesson here:

Good Preparation Makes it Easier to Improvise

Since I am an improviser, I get a lot of funny looks and joking comment when I talk about preparing. If I say, “I have to get home and prepare for a speech I am doing next week,” someone will invariably respond, “prepare? Aren’t you an improviser? Can’t you just “wing it?””

Well sure, I suppose I could improvise, but just because you can do something doesn’t mean you necessarily should. I have a third degree black belt. I could kill you my bear hands, but does that mean I should? I think not…

The ability to improvise is a valuable tool. It allows you to react when things go off plan (and they will), but it still helps to have a plan. It allows you to not worry about over-preparing, but doesn’t mean you should under-prepare.

In our story, the first unexpected event was not the books falling out of the bag. The first unexpected event was, “him showing up a minute late and the bus already being there.” This led to him reacting (running for the bus) which led to the second un unexpected event (the books falling out).

Two seconds of prep up front (properly zipping up the bag) would have allowed him to easily improvise with the second event. Bad prep, and his troubles got worse and worse.

Ah,. the original master of improvisation. You know MacGyver was always prepared with his duct tape and pocket knife. And probably a hair dryer and can of hairspray...

Ah,. the original master of improvisation. You know MacGyver was always prepared with his duct tape and pocket knife. And probably a hair dryer and can of hairspray...


You can apply this idea to any area of life. Having some emergency cash saved up makes it easier to deal with your car breaking down. Staying in touch with friends and colleagues makes it easier to react to getting laid off. Keeping the phone number of the person you are meeting in your cell phone makes it easier to deal with getting stuck in traffic. Keeping your most important items in your carry on bag makes it easier to handle an airline losing your luggage. And the list goes on and on.

There is no possible way you can eliminate the need to improvise. The universe is an unpredictable place, and things will always go a little askew. Ding Happens! But if you cover the basic fundamentals in your preparation, you will be much more able to handle life’s curveballs.

Question: What can you be doing this very day to increase your preparation and therefore improve your ability to improvise?

Posted in Ding!, Motivation & Success | 3 Comments

Flow With the Go

No, the title of this post is not a typo. It is a different take on how to approach the concept of “flow.”

Yesterday, I was reading Guy Kawasaki’s The Art of the Start: The Time-Tested, Battle-Hardened Guide for Anyone Starting Anything, and he used the phrase “Flow with the Go.” He didn’t really explain it much, but that phrase has been bouncing around in my head ever since I read it.

The traditional phrase is, of course, “go with the flow.” This may seem like a good phrase for an improviser. However, there is an implies passivity to “go with the flow.” The phrase makes it sound like you should just release and let life take you wherever it will, regardless of where you want to go. Kind of like being in a river and instead of swimming against the current, you just float along with the river.

Not a terrible philosophy, and better than struggling with resistance, but the problem with that approach is you don’t exert any control where the river (i.e. life) will take you. If you simply “go with the flow,” all the time, you may find yourself flowing right over a waterfall…

“Flow the Go,” creates a slightly different impression. Rather than going with things that are already flowing, you direct your flow with towards things that are already going. It’s the difference between letting go while in the river and choosing which river to jump into in the first place.

When you flow with the go, you find what’s going; ideally, you find what’s going towards where you want to go. Then you stop resisting and struggling against that and flow along with it.

Rather than flow being a passive response to existing conditions, it becomes and active way of using existing conditions to help you get what you want.

Question: Where is the “go” in your life? What is that little voice inside you urging you to do? What do friends keep telling you you are great at? What seemingly random coincidence keep popping up in your life as if to say, “hey dumbass, pay attention to me!”?

Stop ignoring or resisting them. Pay attention, take a deep breath, jump into the river of your choosing and “flow with the go.”

Posted in Motivation & Success | Leave a comment

5 Great Motivational Songs From 80’s Movies

Everyone can use a little motivation from time to time, and what better form of motivation is there than great music? Er..except for the Motivational Smart Ass blog, that is…

I grew up in the 80’s and have a soft spot for the “so bad they’re great” songs and movies of that era. Here are five songs from 80’s movies that both musically and lyrically get me pumped up whenever I hear them. Throw them on your iPod and crank ’em up the next time you hit the gym or go for a run!

You’re the Best

The Karate Kid

You’re the best!
Around!
Nothing’s gonna ever keep you down

How can you top a chorus like that? You can’t!

Trust me, if you grew up in the 80’s, trained in the martial arts, and have ever gone to a karate tournament, you can not help but hear this song in your head. It is a physical impossibility.

For motivation, there’s nothing quite like hearing a guy telling you over and over again that “you’re the best! Around!” Too good…

Bonus Motivational Lyrics:
Never doubt that you’re the one
And you can have your dreams!

Wikipedia Trivia Note: The song was originally intended for Rocky III but was replaced by “Eye of the Tiger.”

Win in the End

Teen Wolf

Win in the end
I’m gonna win in the end

This is probably one of the more obscure songs on the list, and I have no idea how or why it has stuck out in my head all these years, but this is one of favorites. Come on – a song has to amazing if it can inspire a basketball team led by a non-Wolfed up Michael J. Fox (who is what, like 5’2″?) and Francis from Pee Wee’s Big Adventure to win a game.

This is a good song for when you feel like the world is using you as its own personal punching bag. Of course, if you don’t like phat 80’s synth, you may want to skip this one.

Bonus Motivational Lyrics:
I will steal the thunder
Rolling out from under
Every cloud that’s clashing in the sky

Like a true defender
I will not surrender
Why should I lie down for them and die?

Wikipedia Trivia Note: There is no Wikipedia entry for “Mark Safan,” or “Win in the End.” How is that for obscure?

Hearts on Fire

Rocky IV

Hearts on Fire
strong desire
rages deep within

I know, you’re thinking, “What about ‘Eye of the Tiger’ or ‘No Easy Way Out’?” Fine songs both, but for hardcore motivational pumpitude, you can not beat “Hearts on Fire.”

High energy, great lyrics and a great running pace. Interestingly, I always made sure to put this song at the end of my running mix because I would speed up considerably when it came on. Now that’s motivational.

What male child of the 80’s didn’t at some point visualize themselves as Rocky knocking out Drago, or running up a mountain, or cleaving logs with a single blow, or grabbing picture of their mortal enemy off a mirror and crumpling it up? We all did it, and now, with the power of music, you can do it over and over again!

Bonus Motivational Lyrics:
time will not allow you to stand still, no
silence breaks the heart and bends the will
and things that give deep passions are your sword
rules and regulations have no meaning anymore

Wikipedia Trivia Note: “According to singer Peter Cetera, he originally wrote his best-selling solo single “Glory of Love” as the end title for this film, but was passed over by United Artists, and instead used as the theme for The Karate Kid Part II.” Ech. Could you imagine “Glory of Love” in Rocky IV??

Best of the Best

Best of the Best

Put yourself to the test
Be the best of the best!

Another obscure one, but man, when growing up there was a period where I watched this movie everyday after school. Not the whole movie, just a couple of fight scenes and the training montage set to “Best of the Best.”

This is a good one for motivation because it’s all about pushing through when things get hard or painful, which, if you’re trying to achieve anything of note, they will.

Bonus Motivational Lyrics:
You have to stand up and fight
When the challenge is right
Through the tears and the pain
Still the glory remains

Wikipedia Trivia Note: This little “so bad it’s good movie” stars not one but two – count ’em, two – Academy Award nominated actors. James Earl “Don’t call me Darth Vader” Jones from the Great White Hope and Eric “Don’t call me Julia’s brother” Roberts from Runaway Train.

St. Elmo’s Fire

St. Elmo’s Fire

I can see a new horizon
Underneath the blazin’ sky
I’ll be where the eagle’s
Flyin’ higher and higher
Gonna be your man in motion
All I need is a pair of wheels
Take me where my future’s lyin’
St. Elmo’s Fire

This is not only a great 80’s motivational song, but it’s also just a great song period. Great music, lyrics, and very motivational. I don’t care what mood you’re in; listening to this song will automatically take you up a few notches.

I honestly have no idea how the song relates to the movie. I guess they talk about “St. Elmo’s Fire,” (the natural phenomenon) at the end, but that’s pretty thin. The song is a high energy anthem of inspiration. The movie is basically a telling of what would happen to the Breakfast Club if they all became dumbasses or coke-heads. Oh well…

Bonus Motivational Lyrics:
Play the game
You know you can’t quit until it’s won
Soldier on
Only you can do what must be done

Wikipedia Trivia Note: “The song was originally written by David Foster and John Parr for the Canadian athlete Rick Hansen, who at the time was going around the world in his wheelchair to raise awareness for spinal cord injuries.” (Sort of makes the whole, “All I need is a pair of wheels,” line make a lot more sense, eh?)

Posted in Just Funny, Motivation & Success | Tagged | 15 Comments

It’s Gonna Get Worse Before it Gets Better

Ah, the wit and wisdom of Roadhouse...

Ah, the wit and wisdom of Roadhouse...

“Pain don’t hurt”
– Dalton (Patrick Swayze), Roadhouse

Sadly, yes, pain does hurt. I learned this last week when my teeth and gums decided it was time to pay me back for a few years of neglect. Were the lessons on business and success worth the pain I went through? You be the judge…

A couple of weeks ago I developed a some tooth pain. One morning I woke up and the upper right part of my mouth just hurt. Uh oh…

I was on the road for some speaking gigs, and had about four days before I could get back to see a dentist. To complicate matters, I didn’t actually have a Philadelphia dentist. Yes, I was still using the dentist I grew up with in NY state, trying to time appointments with visits to my parents. This plan had been relatively unsuccessful (come on! who wants to take time to see the dentist when your are only visiting your parents for a couple of days??) so I hadn’t been to the dentist for a few years. I know, I know, more fool me…

Life lessons from dentistry - who knew?

Life lessons from dentistry - who knew?


I managed to suffer through the next few days. The pain came and went, ranging from a low, dull throb to a “oh good God make it go away!” level.

While on the road, I got recommendations from my Philly friends and made an appointment for the day after I got back with a Philadelphia dentist. Yes, at 36 years old it was finally time to cut the cord and get a local DDS.

I went in to the appointment both nervous and hopeful. Nervous that it would be something serious requiring surgery or a “major procedure,” hopeful that I would walk out of there with my pain gone.

The dentist was a nice man who examined me closely and even took an x-ray. There was good news and bad news.

  • The good news: There was nothing major wrong. In fact, it wasn’t tooth pain, it was gum pain, most likely caused by years of accumulated plaque (did I mention I flossed only about once a year…?). I only needed a good cleaning, and the problem would go away.
  • The bad news: I would not walk out of there pain free. The cleaning would allow the gum to heal, but it would have to heal on its own. Even worse, the dentist says, “by clearing the plaque, we’ve exposed parts of the gum that were covered up, so they’ll be sensitive. Chances are the pain will get worse before it gets better.” He said it would take about 4 days.

D’oh!

This was unfortunate. I was hoping to walk out of there with a magic cure that would make my pain stop this moment. Instead, I was going to have to be in more pain for 4-7 more days!

And let me tell you, he wasn’t kidding. Three nights later I woke up in the middle of the night with the worst mouth pain I had felt since this whole thing started. And this was after taking two ibuprofens!

I was beginning to wonder if my dentist was a quack. He had said “about 4 days.” Well if that was the case, shouldn’t day three have had less pain? Maybe it was infected! Maybe there was something fa worse wring he had missed!

But no, there was nothing else wrong. each day after that the pain and throbbing got a little less. Today is the one week mark from the appointment and I barely noticed it at all. Turns out the dentist was right: it got worse before it got better, but it eventually got better. I suppose there is something reassuring in knowing that your dentist knows what he is talking about.

This got me thinking about the concept of pain, suffering, and success in other areas as well. There are a few takeaways from my dental ordeal:

Maintenance is Easy; Easy to Do, But Also Easy to Skip

I could have avoided this whole experience if I had done two simple things:

  1. Flossed regularly
  2. Seen the dentist every six months (heck, even once a year would have staved off this pain)

Is it safe? No, not if you skip basic mainenance...

Is it safe? No, not if you skip basic mainenance...

Neither of these is hard or time consuming, but they are still easy to put off.

In life and business, there are many things we can be doing every day to just maintain (or slightly improve) our business, health, relationships, etc. They are easy to put off and seem inconsequential, but put them off long enough and they will bite you in the ass.

The Question For You: What simple day to day “maintenance” activities are you putting off doing that, when you think about it, you know will come back to haunt you?

Disaster is Usually Preceded by Warning Signs

Here’s a confession: I had a similar pain years ago. My dentist told me it was just gum sensitivity and told me to use a soft bristled toothbrush and start using a “sensitive” toothpaste, like Sensodyne. This kind of depressed me as this was the toothpaste my parents used – I had always looked at it as “old people’s toothpaste.” And now I had to use it.

A couple of years later, that tooth/gum area would hurt if I bit down on something wrong. Guess what I did? That’s right, I would think, “hmm, I should see the dentist,” and then proceed to do nothing about it.

I ignored the signs, and I paid for it.

Most things that we see as “crisises” in our lives come with some advance warning. Business starts to drop before it bottoms out, communication gets tough before relationships end, and minor chest pains often precede major heart attacks. We just need to a) notice them and b) do something about it.

And it’s the second one that’ll get ya’…

The Question For You: What warning signs, in your business, health, or personal life are you ignoring right now?

Fixing Things Hurt (For a Bit)

Like my dentist told me, “it’s going to get worse before it gets better.” Fixing, or improving things, usually requires some kind of pain, suffering, or sacrifice. Getting in great shape requires sweat at the gym. Starting a business requires cutting back on spending and fun for a bit. Bad relationships require either difficult conversations or painful endings.

Does this mean that all improvement comes with pain and suffering? Not necessarily. Sometimes you find an elegant solution that makes everyone happy, an easy way to get what you want, or a resolution that makes everyone happy. But being willing to suffer if needed gives you the strength and courage to take actions to make things better.

A little (or lot) of short term pain can lead to a lifetime of great happiness. But it may get worse before it gets better.

The Question For You: What are you avoiding doing because you are afraid of the short term pain? How is that going to hurt you in the long run?

Dentists get a bad rap, but not from me! I am no anti-dentite!

Dentists get a bad rap, but not from me! I am no anti-dentite!

Let’s be blunt: pain sucks, but it’s a part of life. With proper maintenance and vigilance, you can reduce and avoid a lot of it. But sometimes you’re going to have to deal with it. If you’re not willing to have things be worse for a while, then you’ll never get to a point where things get better. Now go do what you have been avoiding.

And remember to floss your teeth!

Posted in Business Advice, Motivation & Success | 1 Comment

How to Make Some Smart Ass Decisions

We all make awful decisions from time to time. Some people make awful decision more frequently then just “from time to time.” But have you ever thought about why you make the decisions you do and what goes into the decision making process? I was inspired to do this myself after a recent trip to a casino…

I was in Las Vegas for this year’s The Speaking School, and one night we found ourselves sitting at a Three Card Poker table.

Vegas baby, Vegas! <br /> (Photo by Jam Adams)

Vegas baby, Vegas!
(Photo by Jam Adams)

I know, Three Card Poker is a sucker’s game with some terrible odds, but it’s fun. Besides, it’s called gambling. If you don’t want to (or can’t afford to) lose, don’t gamble.

I’ve played Three Card Poker before, and using the friendly odds information over at Wizard of Odds I knew that in Three Card Poker your best strategy is to stay in on anything better than a Queen-six-four off-suit (don’t worry if you don’t know what that means. All you need to know is that I had researched the statistically best odds of winning – or “losing less quickly,” as it were…)

While at the table, the dealer notices a few of us staying in on these types of “Queen-high” hands. She says, “You shouldn’t stay in with just a Queen.”

My friend replies, “why not?”

“Because the best you can hope for is a push.” (A “push” is basically a tie – you neither win nor lose money)

Now I chime in. “Oh? I thought statistically it’s best to stay in on anything better than Queen-six-four…”

“In my experience, people usually lose when they stay in with queens,” the dealer answers. “I recommend people stay in only when they have King or better.”

Ah-ha! Therein, my friends, lies the crux of this story. “In my experience.” Three simple, powerful, and often incredibly limiting words.

“In my experience,” is just one type of evidence. To be able to make informed decisions, we must understand and evaluate three types of evidence: intuition, anecdotal, and data.

Intuition

Intuition - Trust your gutThis is simply your “gut” feeling. When you are about to make any decision, you probably have an initial immediate feeling as to which is the best choice. Some people put a lot of stock in their intuition. Others don’t value it at all.

Neither one is right or wrong. Just be aware when you are making a decision based on intuition. Where you might get yourself into trouble is when you have a gut feeling and then simply look for anecdotal evidence and data to support your intuition, rather than being objective about it. This happened everyday, especially in “soft” areas such as relationships. If you like someone, you will ignore stories and examples of them acting like a dumbass and focus on their good qualities. Likewise, if you decide someone is a jerk, you will create a mental catalog of all of their dumbass behavior and ignore or explain away their nice deeds.

This is not to say you should not go with your gut. Some of the greatest innovations of our time have come from people ignoring data and anecdotal evidence to pursue what they felt was right. Just know that this is what you are doing. (By the way, history is also littered with many more examples where people ignored data and evidence and failed miserably. We just don’t talk about them as much. So be careful

Anecdotal

Stories can be powerful, but be careful! They can mislead

Stories can be powerful, but be careful! They can mislead

“Anecdotal” is just a fancy-schmancy way of saying “based on personal observations.” (Yes, paraphrased that definition from dictionary.com)

For most of our small decisions, many of our medium sized decisions, and quite a few of our large decisions, we rely on personal observations and stories passed along from other people. We are shaped by our own experiences, and we make gross generalizations based on a few specific examples.

For example, you have a bad first experience at a restaurant, so you assume it sucks and never go back. A friend tells you Lowe’s is targeted to women and you assume it’s true. You always have nice pleasant conversations with your neighbor so you are shocked when he turns out to be a serial killer.

Anecdotal evidence may be the most persuasive and powerful form of evidence. This is why great speakers use stories. I even wrote a post about how to quickly put together a speech and stressed the importance of stories. We want to trust our gut, and we like data, but we trust what our eyes and ears tell us.

This is what the dealer at the Three Card Poker table did. In her personal experience, people who stay in with “Queen high” lose, so it’s better to stay in on “King high” or better. A card game like Three Card Poker is nice because there is straight statistical data to tell us whether she was right or wrong. In this case her her opinion on optimum strategy was wrong, and that is because there are some problems relying on just anecdotal evidence:

  • It’s incomplete – Like in the case of the quiet neighbor who turns out to be a psycho, anecdotal evidence rarely tells us the whole story. Was the person you just met rude because he’s a jerk or because he has a tooth ache, his pet died, and he just got served with divorce papers? Who knows. But relying purely on anecdote, you’ll assume he’s a jerk.

    The Three Card Poker dealer’s evidence was incomplete. She wasn’t paying attention to the value of playing for a “push.” While the chances of “winning” are incredibly low, playing for a “push,” helps you lose money less quickly.

  • It’s selective – You can’t observe everything. You may observe hundreds of cases every week of BMW drivers driving nice and cautiously. But when one cuts you off, you suddenly have anecdotal evidence that “all BMW drivers are jerks.”

    The dealer probably dealt many hands where a “Queen high” pushed, and even a few where it won. But when it came to decision time, she forgot or ignored all of these.

  • It’s biased – As mentioned above in the section on intuition, if you already have an idea in mind, your brain may start looking for stories to support your point while ignoring all evidence to the contrary.

    Through the course of the rest of the night, the Three Card Poker dealer was quick to point out the cases where staying in on “Queen-high” lost. I don’t think she noticed or cared when it pushed.

Be very wary of making decisions based purely on anecdotal evidence. These are often the ones that bite you in the ass.

Data

Data is great, but not infallible...Data is simply information. In card games, data comes down to straight statistics. Looking at data is easy if you are talking about card games (and are a statistician. Frankly, number crunching like that eludes me. I took four semesters of calculus in college and I still can’t wrap my head around probability and statistics!)

For non-statistical stuff, data comes down to research: surveys, focus groups, sales numbers, etc.

Data is wonderful, but not infallible. Here are some limitations of data:

  1. It’s limited to the sample set – Data may seem like a great way to figure out what people want, but in reality you are often only getting data on the people surveyed! What that means is that you may think you are getting a cross section of the market when in reality you are not.

    If your customer feedback forms say, “service was great!” well, your service may be great. Or it could be that the few people who took the time to fill out a feedback form liked the service, whereas the vast majority who hated the service left without saying or doing anything.

  2. It relies heavy on the questions asked – The way a question is asked can heavily influence the answer you get. There’s a frequently cited study (I read about it in both Predictably Irrational and Super Freakonomics) that demonstrates this:

    A large group of people were given $300 and then told that they could a) get an extra $100 or b) flip a coin, and if they won they would get an additional $200, but if they lost they would get nothing. About 65% chose option a.

    Then, in a similar situation, a large group of people were given $500 and then told that they could a) have $100 taken away from them or b) flip a coin, and if they won they would keep their money, but if they lost they would lose $200. In this case, about 65% of the people chose option b.

    Interesting, no? The two outcomes are exactly the same. Pick option “a” and you get $400. Pick option “b” and you have a 50% chance of getting $300, and a 50% chance of getting $500. The only difference is in how they options were setup, and it resulted in very different responses.

    I won’t go into the psychological ramifications of this study. But when it comes to data, it shows how biased “objective” data can be based on word choice.

  3. It keeps us in the world of what we know – Data is great, but only lets us measure what we know. It’s hard to gather data on innovative ideas, because they don’t yet exist. After Apple’s flop with the Newton PDA, data may have indicated that there was no interest in a portable device that served as your phone, email system, music player, video player, game system, and total life manager all in one. And yet, now we have the iPhone (which is awesome!
  4. It may not tell the whole story – Gathering data is one thing. Understanding and analyzing it is quite another. You launch a promotional campaign and see sales numbers go up. The campaign must have worked, right? Maybe, maybe not. Maybe a tour bus happened to stop in front of your establishment one day which jacked up your numbers. Maybe word of mouth hit the tipping point. Maybe you got lucky. It can be hard to tell, which is why very deliberate tracking of activities is so vital.

    Smart people understand that there is a difference between causation and correlation. Dumb people make assumptions.

So which one of these forms of evidence is best? None. Or all.

Unless you are engaging in a purely statistical activity (like Three Card Poker) you need to weigh all three forms of evidence in your decision making process.

Buying a home? Listen to your gut, but also talk to people in the area and look up some data on crime rates, school ratings, etc.

Want to start a business? Do some market research, talk to both people in the industry and to potential customers, and then listen to your intuition.

Gambling at a casino? Ignore the dealer and trust The Wizard of Odds. Sorry, had to be said – besides, those games are straight stats!

Whichever decision making route you take just be aware of which strategy you are employing and why. Doing that one simple thing alone may help you make better, less disastrous, more “Smart Ass” choices!

Attribution: I want to give credit where credit is due. I first came across the “intuition-anecdotal-data” idea on decision making while at a National Speakers Association event. Stephen Tweed was the nice and smart gentleman who taught me this process. Thanks Steve!

Posted in Business Advice, Motivation & Success | 1 Comment

Thanksgiving Humor: Rain on My Parade – Please!

(Note: This is a repost of some Thanksgiving humor I wrote a couple of years ago – enjoy!)

Thanksgiving Day is approaching here in the U.S., and that means that on a very cold Thursday morning thousands of people will be lining up to watch the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. I’ll admit it, I don’t get parades. They bore the heck out of me. Maybe it’s because I’m more of a “doer” than a “watcher,” but I can think of few less interesting ways to spend an afternoon. If my life were made into an existential play by Sartre, my Waiting Room would be on the streets of Manhattan watching the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day parade.

Ah! We’re being attacked by a giant frog! Oh, wait. it’s just the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade... <br /> (Photo by cogito ergo imago)

Ah! We’re being attacked by a giant frog! Oh, wait. it’s just the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade...
(Photo by cogito ergo imago)

Parades in the summer are bad enough, but a parade in late November? What’s the appeal of standing in the cold watching people slooooowly walk by? Is it the balloons? The floats? Come on, that’s fun for about twenty-three seconds, tops. Maybe it’s like the old joke: “Q: Why are you hitting yourself in the head with a hammer? A: Because it feels so good when I stop!” There are few feelings better than one you get when you finally leave a parade…

You know what’s worse than going to see a parade live? Watching one on TV. You get all the boredom of slowly moving participants without any of the excitement of an energized crowd or the spectacle of seeing large balloons up close in person.

To be fair, I’d rather watch a parade on TV because with one click of the remote I can be watching something far more interesting. Like four straight hours of the Weather Channel. It is also a lot warmer in my living room than on the streets of Manhattan. This is why watching the Weather Channel would be more fun – I can see exactly how cold it is on the parade route and laugh to myself while I relax in my jammies and pour myself a second cup of hot cocoa.

Obviously, society does not agree with me at all. Thousands and thousands of people come out to watch this parade, and over forty million people watch it on TV. And hey, if it’s on TV, it can’t be bad, right? There’s even a song titled, “I Love a Parade.” Obviously this was written by a lonely, lonely person who was desperate to find love anywhere. Maybe I’ll write a song titled, “I Love a Root Canal.” And where did the saying, “don’t rain on my parade come from?” If I got dragged to a parade I would be praying for rain so I could go home. But if the rest of the world likes parades so much, then maybe I’m missing something.

Or maybe, just maybe, I am the lone voice of wisdom in an insane world. I’ll say it, “the emperor has on no clothes! Parades are boring!”

I’m going to throw on my professional speaker/storyteller/writer hat here for a moment. We live in a storytelling culture. Since before man could write, information was conveyed as stories. TV, movies, theater – all appeal on their ability to tell a story. The best songs tell stories, whether lyrically or symbolically with the progression of the music. Sporting events tell stories: who’s going to win, how is it going to happen? Even advertisers and marketers know, the best advertising tells a story.

What’s the story in a parade? “Underdog needed to get across town, and he couldn’t catch a cab (you know how it is when you are a superhero dog in New York City), so he decided to fly slowly down 7th avenue to get there. Oh, and he’s followed by a horde of other outdated characters and a large crowd of dancers and floats.”

No story. No interest.

If, on the off chance that you happen to be a “parade designer” – is that a real job? – here’s a challenge. Design a parade that tells a story. Have Matt Lauer and Meredith Viera weave a tale that involves everyone from the first high school marching band to the final giant Pickachu float bringing up the rear. Make it all part of a story. Draw me in, progress the action, and wrap it up. Is that too much to ask?

There are, however three exceptions to the “parades are boring” theory:

  1. I understand ticker tape parades and parades to honor vets. Those make sense – get everybody out there and cheer and support. That’s great. Like a giant adult pep rally.
     
  2. If you have children who are at an age where anything new and shiny makes them smile and giggle, then sure, you take them to see it. It’s one of those things parent sacrifice for their kids, like a social life and any semblance of clean pants. That doesn’t mean the parade is any good – you can get the same wide eyed giggles out of your child by clapping your hands and saying “ba-ba-ba-ba-ba” over and over. So there you go – a parade is the adult version of baby talk.
     
  3. On New Year’s Day in Philadelphia there is the Mummers Parade, which is a *huge* deal. I have never been to it, but everyone raves about it. This is for two reasons.
     
    1. There are four different competitions within the parade where teams are awarded some serious money for funniest, best costume, best music, etc. Granted, the prize money is a small fraction of what the teams spend on their costumes (seriously – each costume can run a couple of thousand dollars). But that makes it a competition, not just a parade, which means there’s a – wait for it- STORY! As an observer you’re not just watching the parade, but you are also trying to figure out who is going to win.
       
    2. Everyone gets drunk. The parade starts in the morning, and so too does the drinking. New Year’s Eve is not super huge or crazy in Philly, and I think that’s because people are saving themselves for the craziness of New Year’s Day. There is a palpable energy in the air on New Year’s Day in Philly as the whole city is alive (and drunk). So of course they enjoy the parade. Even Waiting for Godot would be fun if the audience was tanked. (There’s an idea: something along the lines of “The Rocky Horror Waiting for Godot Show”) Hmm…maybe I should try this Mummers thing.
       

If you are a die hard parade enthusiast, then more power to you. I just don’t get it. And if you agree with me, then I hope you enjoy the warmth and comfort of your home this year as you do anything but attend a parade!

Have a safe and Happy Thanksgiving!

Posted in Just Funny | 2 Comments

When Common Sense and Customer Service Collide

Do you know what, “smack yourself in the head because it is so unbelievably idiotic customer service,” is? Probably, but in case you don’t (and to read some ideas on how to fix it) keep reading…

I was at Barnes and Nobles with my friend Fred Gleeck (we were in Las Vegas during our November Speaking School). Fred needed to return a book. B&N was slow this evening and there as no line, so we walk right up to the register. When we tell the girl there want to return something, she says she has to call her manager. No problem, we’ll wait.

A woman then walks up into line behind us. Fred says to the cashier, “why don’t you help her while we wait?”
“I can’t,” the B&N employee responds.

“Oh, did you already start entering this into the system?”

“No, I am just not supposed to push customers aside to help the next in line.”

“But I’m saying it’s ok,” Fred responds. “I don’t mind.”

“I still can’t. It’s out policy. I am supposed to stay 100% focused on the current customer.”

Fred is (understandably) exasperated at this. “But it shouldn’t matter. I’m the person being pushed aside and I say it’s ok.”

“I still can’t. I’m not supposed to, and I don’t want to get into trouble with my boss. They have cameras and stuff.”

What.

The.

Heck?!

Today’s customer service brought to you by Big Brother! Silly, silly...

Today’s customer service brought to you by Big Brother! Silly, silly...


This is a common case of policy gone wrong. A rule designed to help give “great customer service,” ends up inconveniencing customers. And it comes across as ridiculously stupid.

Why do companies assume that a series of rules will be able to cover any and all situations that arise? Have they never lived a day in the world and realized that weird stuff will happen?

Rules are good, as guidelines. But to demand slavish adherence to those rules in customer service situations is ridiculous.

In this story, the girl was clearly unwilling to do something different because “big brother was watching.” Are we, as a workforce, so unbelievably stupid as that we can not be trusted with a modicum of free will and judgment? (Ok, based on some of my blog posts, there are a lot of people that can not be trusted with judgment. But I refuse to say we should throw our hands up in the air and give up. We can not let stupidity win out! Rage, rage against the dying of the light!)

I understand that the franchise, “e-myth,” model is often cited as a key to success, but how we can you apply a rigid system to something as unpredictable as human interaction? You can’t!

It’s easy and makes perfect sense to systematize the making of a hamburger. There is no randomness to it, it can be taught, and it ensures that every customer gets the same burger experience every time. The same can not be said of communication. Everyone is different, ergo every situation is different.

Customer service needs to be taught as a series of guiding principles, not as a series of fixed policy rules. Employees need to be trained on how to communicate effectively and with consideration, not on how to follow a step by step flowchart that may or may not apply. Employees who are too inconsiderate, rude, stupid, or apathetic to learn and follow the principles should be replaced (or at least moved from customer interaction situations).

And that, my friends, is how you avoid having, “smack yourself in the head because it is so unbelievably idiotic,” customer service.

Posted in Business Advice | Tagged | 4 Comments

Compliments: Take ‘Em Like a Man!

A couple of days ago I wrote a post on The Immense Power of an Unsolicited Compliment. My friend Terry Ryan pointed me to a post he made on his blog a while ago on the converse: Always Accept Compliments.

Give it a read – he’s got a good point. If someone goes out of their way to compliment you, accept it with a simple “thank you.” Not only is graciously accepting praise good for your self-esteem, but it also allows the compliment giver to feel good for their small action. This is “win-win” people!

So to all you who emailed or posted nice words regarding the “Unsolicited Compliment” article: Thank you.

Posted in Motivation & Success | 3 Comments