What We All Can Learn From NBC’s Heroes’ Suckitude
NBC’s Heroes is awful. Just awful. So why do I still watch? Because a) I am evidently a masochist who is quickly trying to kill my brain cells and b) I still have hope that it will return to it’s former glory. That hope may very well be misguided.The show is so uninteresting that rather than pay attention, I find myself pondering why exactly it has gotten so bad. I have come up with a few reasons, and think there are some great business lessons in there we can all learn from. Even if you have never watched Heroes (and if not, I suggest watching season 1 and then pretending the show got cancelled at that point), you can still learn from their (bad) example.
Start Strong
Season 1 of Heroes was one of the best things ever on TV, and I was sucked in instantly. It stayed excellent right up until the end.
Season 2 started and it, well, was kind of awful. “But that’s ok!” I justified. “There was a writer’s strike! And a lot of shows have a ‘sophomore slump.’ It’ll get better.”
Then season 3 hit. It started a little better than season 2, but quickly stank up the joint.
Season 4, so far, has been pretty bad too. *sigh*
So why do I keep watching? Because season 1 was soooooo good. I keep remembering what it was, wanting it to be that, hoping that one day it will. My hope is wearing thin now, but it has carried me through over 2 seasons worth of episodes.
On the flip side, there have been other new shows that I was excited to start watching, such as Fox’s Fringe, which did not grab me and so I gave up. I have now heard that Fringe is quite good, but I have long since let go of my desire to watch it.
The Business Lesson: First Impressions Matter. If a customer or prospect has a great first experience they may forgive a bad second or third experience. This is not to say that if you knock it out of the park the first time that you can coast. But if you start strong you earn trust and loyalty.
Move Forward
My biggest pet peeve with Heroes now is that nothing happens! Not only does practically nothing happen between the start of an episode and the end, but it seems like they rehash the same basic stories year after year.
Hiro screwed up the past! Peter is angsty about his powers! Seiler is ridiculously powerful but has forgotten who he is! Someone accidentally saw Claire use her powers!
Has there been a season where these things haven’t happened? It’s no fun watching small variations on the same story year after year after year.
The Business Lesson: Keep growing The world is constantly changing and evolving. If you are doing the same things now that you were doing five years ago, guess what? You’re being left behind. You don’t need to reinvent the wheel every year, but constant growth improvement should be a top priority.
(P.S. Astute readers will recognize this as the Yes, And principle I talk about…)
Don’t Lose Trust
You know, season 4 may not be the worst thing ever. I wonder, if this week’s episode had been shown in season 1, would I feel much better about it?
But Heroes has been bad for so long now that an “average” episode is not going to make me come back around. At this point, I need something mind blowingly stellar to make me a Heroes believer again.
The Business Lesson: Reputation Matters If you develop a bad rep, justified or not, simply returning back “average status quo” service won’t cut it. Regaining lost trust is much harder than gaining and maintaining it in the first place. The first thing is to obviously not do anything that could hurt your reputation. The second thing, if something has gone wrong, is to remember that you must go above and beyond what you would ordinarily do.
Understand BOTH Your Current and Past Success
When Heroes started, it drew people in by introducing characters and slowly revealing their powers – to both the characters and the viewers. Back then, it made for compelling television. By the end of season 1 though, everyone knew what their powers were and they were working to stop the end of the world. Great stuff.
The problem is that the Heroes team assumed that what made the show work was the slowly paced character and power revel. It was, but only at the beginning. By the end of season 1, what made the show work was the interesting story and the characters we had come to know and love.
When season 2 started, the show once again returned to slowly revealing characters and powers. That sucked. And was boring.
This season seems to be doing the same thing! It’s a superhero show, and your main characters have had years to come to terms with their powers. Let’s start doing something interesting!
Instead it has taken five episodes to finally learn that one new character can destroy things with a cello. This could not have been explained in the opening 2 minutes of the first episode…?
The Business Lesson: Be Honest, and Stop Living in the Past Just because something in your business worked a few years ago doesn’t mean it will still work today. Be brutally honest about what’s working (today), what’s not working (today), and what your customers really care about (today).
Be Likeable
This may be the main reason Heroes has become unwatchable. There is one likeable character on the whole show. Maybe two. And this is on an ensemble show! The rest are either angsty, annoying, or just boring. Many are all three.
How can you have a TV show where all the main characters, the protagonists, are unlikable? Even Gregory House on Fox’s House is more likeable – and his whole character us based around being unlikable!
When this happens, you can sometimes keep watching a show while rooting for the bad guys. Sadly, Heroes’ villains are just as unlikable. *sigh*
The Business Lesson: Be Likeable Simple lesson. People like to do business with people they know, like, and trust. Be nice. Get rapport. Build relationships. And for the love of God, don’t be angsty, annoying, or boring.
Will I keep watching Heroes? Probably, for a few more episodes at least (I have trouble letting go of shows. It’s my curse…) But it is so sad to me how far this show has fallen. My only hope is that we all can learn from their bad example…
***
Are you planning an event and looking for a great speaker to add humor and energy? Then visit Avish’s Conference Speaker page now!
About
By Avish Parashar. As the world's only Motivational Improviser, Avish uses techniques from the world of improv comedy to engage, entertain, and educate audiences on ideas around change, creativity, and motivation. Connect with Avish on Google+
11 Responses to “What We All Can Learn From NBC’s Heroes’ Suckitude”
Comments
Read below or add a comment...
Coincidentally, I just finished watching an episode and thought exactly the same things. My wife is far kinder than I’ll ever be and won’t give up, but I lost hope early last year. Thanks for pinpointing why!
My partner and I watched 15 minutes of season 4 and said “It hasn’t changed” and removed Heroes from the TIVO record list, we have not looked back. Fringe is by far better television.
I will always remember the scene in the first season where Hiro appears on the train. That one scene summed up the potential of the show. Sadly it never lived up to that potential.
I think you’ve missed an important error of the last two seasons (I can’t even bring myself to watch season 4) and a related business lesson:
Don’t just do it to do it
It seems that some time after the first season, the writers stopped making decisions based on plot and characterization and started making them based on a “wouldn’t it be cool if” factor. The first season had an amazing plot arch, were every scene moved us intentionally from the opening credits of episode one to the climax of the final episode. There was a thoughtfulness to the writing that reminded me of shows like Lost (which is a whole other can of worms, I know). But in the later season, the writers stopped asking “what made sense” and stated trying to elicit a “woah” response from the audience, which is not always a good response. Characters changed motivations significantly from one episode to another (Syler suddenly gained and then lost his daddy issues). Plot lines were introduced and then dropped within minutes (Mamma P had a sister for exactly one episode, and for no apparent reason). People changed allegiances, not to make things interesting, but to keep us confused (Noah was on a different side each week of season three and it stopped being intriguing). These things may have kept us guessing, but not about what would happen next, as much as what had just happened. They stopped being true to the vision they had laid out because they thought that the “wow factor” was more important. And so, they became an unfortunate conglomeration of flimsy ideas, carelessly taped together, like a kindergarten art project put together by a kid with ADD.
The Business Lesson: Don’t just do it because it’s cool
So often, businesses make decisions because something is cool, not because it fits with their strategy. In the tech consulting world, we call this the “shiny things” principal, where people in organizations are like cats, instantly infatuated with new shiny things. This is a problematic way to make decisions because you lose people’s trust when they see the lake of depth and vision that you present. Shiny new technologies can be great, when they move you along on your strategic path, but otherwise they are just the junk food of the business world, making us fat, without doing us any good. Our goals should be the scales on which we weigh our decisions.
Dan, is it that your wife is too kind to give in, or is she like me where she desparately keep watching out of a ridiculous fear that it will somehow suddenly get as good as it used to be? I realize how silly that is, especially considering if it were to get good again I could just watch reruns or the DVD when it comes out!
Tom, it’s amazing how many people have responded (here, on FB, and via email) saying the exat same thing as you: that you had similar thoughts and hve already given up on the show. Maybe I’m the last poor schmuck still watching…More fool me, I guess.
Thanks 20Something!
Great comments, and thanks for the write up. You are 100% correct – I remember having similar feelings, especially about the flip-flopping character motivations. I really stopped caring wether HRG, Sylar, Mama P, Nathan P, Suresh, an Tracy/Nikki were good or evil. (Ok, stopped caring about anything Ali Larter’s character did a loooong time agao. Every time I get excited because I finally think they have killed her off, she comes back, even less interesting than before).
There is a funny article at Cracked.com The 5 Most Maddeningly Unresolved TV Plotlines. The first one on the list is how Peter, in season 2, took his Irish (I think) girlfriend to the future, which was kind of apocalyptic, and got separated from her. He made it back to the present, abut never saved her! The article says the writers even admitted to moving on, saying they won’t address it. I think that goes write to your point about the writers stopping asking, “what makes sense.”
Good business point too. Every movement should have a purpose that fits into a larger business strategy.
Thanks!
Oh man, Peter’s lost girlfriend. What a perfect example. It stopped being about the characters who we might actually care about and started being about whatever the writers got excited about. Seems like that writers room runs on the “throw enough poo at the wall and some of it is bound to stick” philosophy.
True. Sadly, very little of the poo is sticking. And now we, the viewers, are left ankle deep in a big steaming pile of poo
It’s better than being left in a nonexistent, post apocalyptic future, I guess. But only marginally…